I've bought 4 sets of tires from Town Fair so far. The pricing has always been the best available, making appointments is easy via the Town Fair website, and the service excellent, including having a tire replaced under the Road Hazard warranty.
Unlike many customers, my tire selection is very specific. The store I go to in Stratford CT has reliably ordered my Bridgestone Pole Position S04, Continental True Contact, and Michelin Pilot Sport Cup 2 tires so they're at the store when I arrive to have the tires mounted and balanced.
Lastly, unlike most customers, I'm an engineer and member of the SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers), so my rating is more critical than a laypersons. Also, people don't use their tires (Michelin Pilot Sport Cup 2's ) for racing - I do (at race tracks, not on the street).
Keep up the good work!